Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog: Which Is The Best Fresh Food For Dogs?

This post contains affiliate links. We earn an affiliate commission when you click our links to purchase products. It has no added cost to you.

Are you thinking about changing your dog’s food to a fresh delivery service; however, maybe you are not sure which brand is the best for your dog. In this article, WhichChoose compares two of the most popular dog food delivery companies: Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog. Before deciding to purchase one of them, you should read some basic information below, such as pricing, nutritional value, meal, treat variety, reputation, and customer service.

Ollie Vs Farmer's Dog: Which Is Better?
Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog: Which Is Better?

The Difference In Ingredients/ Nutritional Value Of Ollie Meal And Farmer Meal?

The difference
The Difference In Ingredients
The Difference In Ingredients
Ollie Meal Farmer’s Dog Meal
Human-Grade Ingredients: 
  • They’re certified throughout the USA and are creators of “human-grade pet food.
  • Grain Free: They have some options of grain-free recipes such as protein (Turkey liver and breast) and other ingredients (kale, carrots, pumpkin, cod liver oil, vitamin E, blueberries, coconut oil, and lentils).
  • Quality Meats and High Protein: Since meat is the main component in any dog meal, it must be quality meat rather than protein fillers or scraps. The lamb and beef are sourced from the USA and Australian farms. Moreover, their chicken is qualified hormone-free. Depending on the recipe, minimum meals will contain 9% to 11% protein content.
  • Human-grade Ingredients: All their vegetables and meats are good enough for people’s consumption.
  • Gently Cooked Meals: Their meals are never cooked at high temperatures; instead, they are cooked gently and frozen immediately to preserve the nutrients.
  • Meals Designed by Veterinary Nutritionists: Like the Ollie brand, their meals are made by veterinary nutritionists. This ensures that they serve the right ingredients and nutrients for your puppy.
  • Strict Safety Standards: Their food is prepared in USDA kitchens to guarantee the safety and highest quality standards.
The Difference In Ingredients/ Nutritional Value Of Ollie Meal And Farmer Meal?

Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog: Meal Options

Meal Options
Ollie Vs Farmer's Dog: Meal Options
Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog: Meal Options

The Meal Options Of Ollie

Ollie Meal Options
Recipe Guaranteed analysis
Chicken recipe: Chicken liver, fish oil, rice, iodized salt, potassium iodide, blueberries, riboflavin (vitamin B2), zinc gluconate, carrots, rosemary spinach, potatoes, peas, chicken gizzard, calcium carbonate, chicken, chia seeds, cod liver oil, dicalcium phosphate, whole dried eggs, copper gluconate, pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin B6), vitamin E supplement. Crude fat: min 3%, crude protein: min 10%, moisture: max 73%; 1298 kcal ME/kg, crude fiber: max 2%.
Lamb recipe: Calcium carbonate, chickpeas, Lamb liver, calcium pantothenate (vitamin B5), potato, butternut squash, dicalcium phosphate, iron sulfate, thiamine hydrochloride., taurine, folic acid, manganese gluconate, lamb, chia seeds, iodized salt, kale, vitamin E supplement, potassium iodate, zinc gluconate, cranberries. Crude fat: min 7%; crude protein: min 10%; moisture: max 74%; 1804 kcal ME/kg; crude fiber: max 2%.
Beef recipe: Iodized salt, peas, riboflavin (vitamin B2), dicalcium phosphate, beef, fish oil, potassium iodide, beef liver, zinc gluconate, beef kidney, potato, sweet potato, vitamin E supplement, blueberries, spinach, rosemary, carrot, beef heart, pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin B6), chia seeds. Crude fiber: max 2%, moisture: max 70%, crude fat: min 7%, 1540 kcal ME/kg, crude protein: min 9%.
Turkey recipe: Zinc gluconate, iron sulfate, iodized salt, coconut oil, pumpkin, manganese gluconate, chia seeds, turkey liver, dicalcium phosphate, vitamin E supplement, carrots, lentils, kale, copper gluconate, manganese sulfate, cod liver oil, potassium iodate, turkey breast, thiamine hydrochloride, blueberries. Crude fat: min 7%, moisture: max 72%, 1390 kcal ME/kg; crude protein: min 11%, crude Fiber: max 2%

Some featured products of Ollie:

Real meat, fruits, veggies, and grains
The pinnacle of quality and nutrition.
Current Deals: 50% OFF check prices
Ease and convenience of kibble without the junk.
Give your pup fresh, healthy food.
An affordable price.
Current Deals: 50% OFF check prices

The Meal Options Of The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog Meal Options
Recipe Guaranteed analysis

Pork recipe: Cauliflower, fish oil, potato, USDA pork liver, green beans, TFD nutrient blend*, USDA pork, sweet potato.

Moisture: 75% max; crude protein: 9% min; 1390 kcal per kg/ 630 kcal per lb; crude fiber: 1.5% max; crude fat: 7% min.

Chicken recipe: USDA chicken liver, TFD nutrient blend*, bok choy, broccoli, USDA chicken, fish oil, brussels sprouts.

Crude protein: 10% min; moisture: 77% max; Crude fat: 6% min; 1300 kcal per kg / 590 kcal per lb; crude fiber: 1.0% max.

Beef recipe: Sunflower seeds, carrot, USDA beef, kale, USDA beef liver, TFD nutrient blend*, sweet potato, fish oil, lentils.

Crude fat: 8% min; crude fiber: 1.5% max; 1530 kcal per kg/ 694 kcal per lb; crude protein: 11% min; moisture: 73% max.

Turkey recipe: Parsnip, TFD Nutrient Blend*, carrot, USDA turkey, fish oil, chickpeas, broccoli, spinach.

Crude fat: 4.5% min; moisture: 76% max; 1170 kcal per kg/ 530 kcal per lb; crude fiber: 1.5% max; crude protein: 9% min.

*TFD nutrient blend ingredients: Potassium iodide, vitamin D3 supplement, tricalcium phosphate, folic acid, vitamin E supplement, vitamin B12 supplement, iron amino acid chelate, taurine, thiamine mononitrate, pyridoxine hydrochloride, sea salt, copper amino acid chelate, Zinc amino acid chelate, riboflavin, choline bitartrate.

A featured product of The Farmer’s Dog:

Key ingredients: Broccoli, carrots, spinach, turkey, chickpeas.
Key ingredients: Beef liver, cooked lentils, carrots, beef, and sweet potatoes.

Farmers Dog Vs Ollie: Customization

Farmers Dog Vs Ollie: Customization
Farmers Dog Vs Ollie: Customization
Customization Ollie The Farmer’s Dog

Supplemental Meal Schedules

Ollie used to serve two supplemental meal plans: Mostly Ollie at 50% of the full amount of food or some Ollie at 25%. Yet, the company has discontinued these plans and only provides them to their current subscribers. The Farmer’s Dog provides a Topper Plan, which permits you to supplement your dog’s daily food. You can choose from some different price and portion options. Your available options will be decreased by the figure for calories your dog requires; therefore, bigger dogs will have more selections from which to choose.

Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog use the information in your dog’s profile (e.g., body type, activity level, age, breed, current weight, medical issues, and known allergies) to select optimal recipes for your puppy. You can mix a variety of meal selections into one shipment or follow with one recipe.

The diversity of meal selections can be helpful if your dog has allergies to particular foods. When making your dog’s profile, you need to add allergies, and both companies will suggest suitable recipes.


Cost Of Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog

Cost Of Ollie Vs Farmer's Dog
Cost Of Ollie Vs Farmer’s Dog

Both companies depend on their pricing on your selected recipes and how much food your dog needs. They determine a specific recipe by the profile you fill out for your puppies, such as ideal weight, body shape, activity level, breed, age, gender, and health issues. Here is the closest price of two companies in the same dog’s profile you can refer to:

65-lb, 3-Year-Old Labrador
38-lb, 1-Year-Old Mixed Breed
11-lb, 5-Year-Old Havanese
50% OFF
Buy Now
65-lb, 3-Year-Old Labrador
38-lb, 1-Year-Old Mixed Breed
11-lb, 5-Year-Old Havanese
Farmers Dog 1
The Farmer’s Dog
No Current Deal
Buy Now
65-lb, 3-Year-Old Labrador
38-lb, 1-Year-Old Mixed Breed

11-lb, 5-Year-Old Havanese

As shown in the table above, Ollie’s price is more affordable than The Farmer’s Dog. Moreover, Ollie provides various meal options; thus, you can easily choose the suitable one for your puppy. Both companies offer free delivery, and you can skip, cancel or pause your subscription anytime.


Customer Support and Reputation

For Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog, customer assistance is available by email and phone seven days a week. Both companies get excellent reviews for their customer service and helpful staff to tackle issues satisfactorily.

Several negative reviews about both companies related to delivery issues (e.g., food items being shipped late or warm), but Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog resolve problems quickly.


The Farmer’s Dog And Ollie Customer Reviews

Customer reviews

Real Customer Reviews About Ollie

On average, Ollie had ratings of 4.3 out of 5.0 from 634 reviews from the Trustpilot and Influenster platforms.

For negative comments, some users reported seeking some grizzle in their dog’s meals. Ollie’s customer service has responded to those reports to sort those instances out. The majority of reviewers say their dogs love Ollie meals and lick the bowl twice.

Some cited their customer service, especially as being “excellent.” This was in terms of solving any issues and meeting custom requests.

Here are some reviews from 2 Ollie fans you can refer to:

5Expert Score

I have been using Ollie meals for the past years for my Bernese, who had experienced severe allergies, and because she has been on this, she has reduced the need for allergy shots, and symptoms of paw and ear infections have reduced. The food has always been delivered in great condition, and she had no problem transitioning to it. I change between the beef and turkey proteins. I hope they add low-risk allergen protein in the future! Thank you, Ollie, for the quality food.

5Expert Score

I love Ollie, and I feel very happy because it exists. I used to go to Petco many times to purchase expensive food that claimed to be great for my dog; however, it looked and smelled atrocious. My dog had terrible gas and always had an upset stomach. After being fed Ollie meals, my dog doesn’t have any stomach or gas issues and loves Ollie’s food.

4Expert Score
Michelle DiBenedetto

The food item is shipped at the frequency that works for me, is on time, and is reliable. One time they sent the wrong portion to me, and customer service addressed it and overnighted me the right size. I like the diversity of meats and treats I can choose from and customize whenever I want.

5Expert Score

For me, Ollie is the best, and I highly recommend it to any dog owner. I believe that eliminating the horrific pet store dog full of chemicals and changing it into Ollie is one of the best decisions I have made in a while!


Real Customer Reviews About The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog fans had much praise for their customer service, which they said “went above and beyond” in some situations. Here are some reviews from customers of The Farmer’s Dog:

5Expert Score
Shelby W

My dog and I really love The Farmer’s Dog! My dog is a Husky, and he likes this food so much. It looks very fresh!

4Expert Score
Doroteya S

My dog Chessy loves The Farmer’s Dog food so much! When I first purchased it for him, Chester did not want any other food. It smells so good and looks like human food. I am so pleased with it, and I know that my puppy not only with a full belly but also absorbs many vitamins from it and a special diet for him. Let’s give it a shot! It is definitely worth the money.


The Farmer’s Dog Vs Ollie: Comparison Table

Comparison Table
  Ollie The Farmer’s Dog
Protein options Lamb, chicken, beef and turkey. Pork, beef, turkey and chicken.
Sourcing Beef and chicken are from high-quality and human-grade farms in the USA, and lamb is taken from free-range farms in the USA and Australia. Oils, produce, and seeds are sourced from USA farms. All ingredients are human-grade and come from renowned food providers, local farms, and other human food purveyors that reach USDA standards.

Recipes made by veterinary nutritionists? Yes Yes
Accreditation AAFCO certified for life stages, USDA certified kitchen and meats. AAFCO certified for life stages, USDA certified kitchen and meats.
Offers treat? Yes, it has four single-ingredient options. No
Supplemental plans Discontinued Yes
Price It starts at 2$ per day. It starts at 2$ per day.
Delivery Free Free
Money-back guarantee? Yes. If your dog is not satisfied, Ollie will give a refund for the starter box. You will receive a full refund if you donate the unused portion to a shelter.
Cancel at any time? Yes Yes
Giving back Ollie donates 1% of its proceeds to rescue shelters and organizations. They also donate meals to rescue shelters frequently. No official charitable donation.

Which Is Better Ollie Or Farmer’s Dog?

Which Is Better?

These dog food provide great quality dog meals and have many reviews from happy customers. Moreover, the protein content in both companies is similar, from 9 to 11% minimum protein levels. 

The significant difference between them is that Ollie has more variety to select from. They provide four meal options and four dog snacks, while The Farmer’s Dog has three options and no snacks. Besides, Ollie’s packaging is more convenient since they offer a scoop to portion the food. They also provide a hard plastic tray for storing the leftovers in the refrigerator. As a result, Ollie is a better option than The Farmer’s Dog because of the variety of meals and high-quality ingredients.

WhichChoose thinks both companies are doing great at what they commit to making high-quality fresh food that helps improve your dog’s nutrition and health. “Ollie vs Farmer’s dog: Which one is the best fresh food for the dog?” depending on your puppy’s needs and interests. We see that Ollie has a bit edge over Farmer’s Dog; however, both customer services are excellent and quick responses.

Enable registration in settings - general