Shopify Vs Etsy: Which Platform Is Better?

Shopify is better than Etsy because Shopify gives your business everything it needs to succeed. Moreover, it includes excellent sales tools, scalable plans, and no selling constraints.

This post contains affiliate links. We earn an affiliate commission when you click our links to purchase products. It has no added cost to you.

Platforms like Shopify vs Etsy have become a significant part of the e-commerce world. Both platforms have their own advantages and disadvantages. This blog from WhichChoose will discuss the pros and cons of the two platforms and which is better.

Shopify Vs Etsy
Shopify Vs Etsy

Shopify Vs Etsy: Overview

Check Prices
Online store.
Sales channels.
Point of sale.
24/7 support.
Amazon Payments.
Check Prices
Customizable banner templates.
Website deals.
Business card discounts.
Email alerts for restocked items.
Credit cards.
Google Pay.
Debit/bank cards.
Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits.
Apple Pay.
Klarna Financing.

1.1. Shopify

Shopify is a third-party platform that assists retailers in creating an online storefront. Vendors may quickly and easily set up shop online without learning how to code or researching hosting companies with premade templates, themes, and other tools and apps.

Shopify’s various available integrations make it easy to run your store with many other programs, which is helpful if you need to do so for whatever reason. Shopify also provides a plethora of good branding and marketing-related tools.

1.2. Etsy

Etsy is a marketplace (like eBay or Amazon). You will join the ranks of the many other online merchants who use Etsy as their storefront. Creating an Etsy shop and launching an online business takes only a few minutes if you follow the simple instructions.

Etsy is a marketplace for unique, handcrafted, antique, and art and craft supplies. It is more of a place for a handmade niche market because most shops sell one-of-a-kind things from skilled and creative artists, designers, or craftspeople.


Shopify vs Etsy: Pros and Cons

Pros & Cons

Dive into the Shopify vs Etsy comparison for the pros and cons in the table below:

Check Prices
Sell infinite products: Selling real items, services, and digital products has no limits.
Shopify is expandable for small and large stores. Upgrade for additional features, branding, and plugins.
Shopify has one of the top e-commerce toolsets. An intuitive inventory system manages, syncs, and monitors orders and supplies.
Small merchants may quickly outgrow the platform because apps and plugins raise monthly costs.
Shopify doesn’t promote. If you don’t have a customer base, it may take a while for people to find you.
Check Prices
Cheap: Etsy’s regular plan doesn’t charge extra for listing and transaction fees. Etsy’s a safe place to start selling online.
It’s user-friendly: Start selling by creating an account, uploading photos and product information.
Etsy already has customers as an online marketplace. Its popularity will attract visitors.
Transaction fees: 5% on each sale and a $0.20 listing fee. Once sales increase, this might significantly reduce profitability.
Restrictions: They specialize in handmade, vintage, and unique items. You couldn’t sell outside this remit.
You cannot change your storefront or branding. You have less control over what a shopper buys and less chance of getting more people to follow you.

Shopify vs Etsy: Ease of Use

Ease of Use
Shopify vs Etsy: Ease of Use
Shopify vs Etsy: Ease of Use

3.1. Shopify

Shopify’s user-friendly interface and wide range of features simplify creating and updating your online store. They also assist you with every step of opening an internet store, such as:

  • Checking in on your stock.
  • Action buttons.
  • Menus.
  • Monitoring your purchases.

3.2. Etsy

To open an Etsy shop, you must first upload at least one product. This can take a long time and a lot of information. However, the information is transferable to other products, and the shipping procedure is something you’ll use repeatedly. Despite this, overall, setting up an Etsy store takes less time.


Shopify vs Etsy: Domain and URL Structure

Domain and URL Structure

4.1. Shopify

Shopify makes getting a unique domain name easy because you can’t build a trustworthy, professional, and memorable brand without a unique URL. This facilitates consumer interaction, search engine visibility, and online credibility.

With Shopify, getting a unique domain name for your online business is easy because the platform is set up automatically.

4.2. Etsy

Etsy stands out from the rest in several ways. You won’t have your own domain name if you utilize Etsy’s marketplace to sell your wares. In its place, your domain might resemble this:

Using Etsy prevents you from having your own domain. If you’re using the Etsy Pattern website builder, you’ll be the only one who can link to your own domain. So, Etsy isn’t fantastic if you want to establish a distinct identity for your brand, but for one-person operations, this shouldn’t be too much of an issue.


Shopify vs Etsy: E-commerce Tools

E-commerce Tools
Shopify vs Etsy: E-commerce Tools
Shopify vs Etsy: E-commerce Tools

5.1. Shopify

Shopify also has a large app store that lets you add any feature you want to your online store. The options for vital add-ons and fine-tuning are practically endless.

In all Shopify plans, you get the following features:

  • Free SSL.
  • Abandoned Cart Recovery.
  • Gift cards.
  • Fraud analysis.
  • Brand assets.
  • Multiplatform social selling.
  • Coupons.
  • Third-party shipping rates.
  • Shopify POS.

Multichannel retailing is crucial to attracting a larger audience and simplifying the buying process for current clients. Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) certificates are a must-have for any site that sells things online, and you can get them for free.

5.2. Etsy

Etsy is solely for selling one-of-a-kind items, vintage items, and creative materials. It may not be the best option if you’re hoping to sell something that doesn’t fit within these categories.

You may subscribe to Etsy Plus if you’re interested in advanced marketing features and want to take your shop to the next level. You gain access to the following:

  • Advertisements.
  • Website deals.
  • Email alerts for restocked items.
  • Customizable banner templates.
  • Business card discounts.

Unlike e-commerce platforms, Etsy is more of a marketplace, so you’ll need to keep track of your stock on your own.


Shopify vs Etsy: Customer Support

Customer Support

Customer Support of Shopify is active 24/7 by live chat, phone, and email. Etsy, on the other hand, this service is active via advertises chat, telephone, and email but only has email support for most concerns


Shopify vs Etsy: Payment Methods, Fees And Pricing

Payment Methods, Fees And Pricing

7.1. Shopify

  • Pricing: Shopify charges a monthly subscription and a transaction fee. After a 14-day free trial, you can choose from three monthly plans:
    • Shopify Basic: $29/month, 2.9% + 30 cents per transaction.
    • Shopify: $79/month, 2.6% + 30 cents each transaction.
    • Advanced Shopify: $299/month, 2.4% + 30 cents each transaction.

The button below will show you what is inside each plan.

Shopify Free 14-day trial
24/7 support.
Point of sale.
Online store.
Sales channels.
  • Fee: Here are some fee Shopify charges:
    • $29-299 monthly plans.
    • Fee-free transactions (if you use Shopify Payments).
  • Payment Methods: Shopify accepts these payments:
    • PayPal.
    • Stripe.
    • Authorize.Net.
    • 2Checkout.
    • FirstData.
    • Amazon Payments.

7.2. Etsy

  • Pricing: Using Etsy does not cost users anything regularly. Nonetheless, there are transaction fees and listing fees to think about:
    • The listing fee is 20 cents per listing plus 20 cents per sale (renewal fee).
    • Payment processing fee: 3% + $0.25.
    • Subscription costs zero or $10 per month for Etsy Plus.
    • Transaction fee: 6.5% of the total cost of each transaction.
Etsy no current deals
Customizable banner templates.
Business card discounts.
Website deals.
Email alerts for restocked items.
  • Fee: Etsy standard fee are:
    • A 5% transaction fee.
    • $10 a month to upgrade to Etsy Plus.
    • A listing fee of $0.20 for each product.
    • A 3% + $0.35 payment processing fee.
  • Payment Methods: Esty offers these methods for payment:
    • Credit cards.
    • Google Pay.
    • PayPal.
    • Debit/bank cards.
    • Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits.
    • Apple Pay.
    • Klarna Financing (United States).
    • iDEAL (the Netherlands).
    • Sofort (Austria and Germany).
    • Klarna installment payments (Australia, United Kingdom, Canada, Spain, United States).
    • Klarna Pay in 30 days (Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Austria, Netherlands, Switzerland, Finland, and Norway).

After reading the Shopify vs Etsy comparison from WhichChoose, both platforms may appear similar at first glance, but Shopify is superior. This is because Shopify has everything you need to run a successful business. In addition to robust selling features and flexible pricing structures, there are no restrictions on the types or quantities of products that can be offered.

Enable registration in settings - general