Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Which Works Better?

As we see in the Medical Guardian vs Philips Lifeline comparison, Medical Guardian is the ideal option for seniors because it provides free activations and over 1300 feet for a landline system.

This post contains affiliate links. We earn an affiliate commission when you click our links to purchase products. It has no added cost to you.

Medical alert devices are becoming an integral part of the life of the senior generation. These devices will alert the emergency response center if they are in trouble. How do you know which one is your perfect option among many devices on the market? In this post, WhichChoose will compare the two popular medical alert systems, Medical Guardian vs Philips Lifeline, to help you pick the right one.

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline
Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline
1

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Overview

Overview
key features
feature products
customer reviews
Medical Guardian
Medical Guardian
50% OFF
Check Prices
key features
Monitor your activities 24/7.
Based on your GPS and wifi connection.
Easy-to-carry with mobile capabilities.
Contains a fall direction function.
feature products
MG Move
Mini Guardian
Home 2.0
Mobile 2.0
Classic Guardian
customer reviews
5/5
Philips Lifeline
Philips Lifeline
No Current Deals
Check Prices
key features
24/7 monitoring of all packages.
Two-way voice communication.
Well-known medical alert system provider.
Lifeline Cares mobile app.
feature products
Mobile on the go
Home safe standard
customer reviews
4/5

1.1. Medical Guardian

Medical Guardian is one of the top picks for the best medical alert providers for older adults. It has an impressive protective range from the at-house base station (more than 1,300 to 1,400 feet) and long battery life. The company also differentiates itself from other competitors due to its high customer reviews for a knowledgeable service team and responsive polite. Here are some feature products of Medical Guardian, as follows:

MGMove 50% OFF
Stay safe 24/7
Track your daily progress
Social Circle Apps to stay in touch
5-day battery life
Crystal clear 2-way speaker
Advanced location tracking
Continuous monitoring services
Mobile 2.0 50% OFF
Long-lasting 5-day battery
Advanced hourly location monitoring
Access to the MyGuardian tool
Connects to your landline telephone
1,300 ft of protection
32 hours of backup battery power
Access to the MyGuardian Portal & App
Home 2.0 50% OFF
Voice Assist Button
4G technology
1,400 ft of protection
Access to the MyGuardian Portal & App

1.2. Philips Lifeline

Philips Lifeline is a medical alert system company, a part of the larger Philips family of tech products. Lifeline concentrates on senior alert devices. Philips Lifeline products consist of an alert button that you can press if you find yourself in a medical case or fell to be connected with an operator that can approach emergency services. Here are some key products of Philips Lifeline:

Home Safe Standard $29.95 per month
In-home communicator.
Two-way voice communication.
Wide range of operation.
Mobile On The Go $49.95 per month
Water-resistant assistance button.
All-in-one system.
Five locating technologies.
2

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Main Features

Features
Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Main Features
Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Main Features
Water-Resistant Wearable Devices
2-Way Voice Communication
Connection
Battery Life
Range (From in-home base unit to help button)
Coverage Away From Home
Fall Detection
GPS Locator
24/7 USA Call Center
Medical Guardian
Medical Guardian
50% OFF
Check Prices
Water-Resistant Wearable Devices
Yes
2-Way Voice Communication
Yes, through mobile pedants, in-home base units, or medical smartwatches.
Connection
Cellular or landline.
Battery Life
More than 24 hours on mobile medical alert devices.
Over 32-hour battery backup on the base unit.
Range (From in-home base unit to help button)
More than 1400 feet for the landline system.
More than 600 feet for cellular in-home systems.
Coverage Away From Home
Yes (on-the-go products)
Fall Detection
Optional (up to $10 per month)
GPS Locator
Yes (on-the-go products)
24/7 USA Call Center
Yes
Philips Lifeline
Philips Lifeline
No Current Deals
Check prices
Water-Resistant Wearable Devices
Yes
2-Way Voice Communication
Yes, through the GoSafe2 pendant or in-home base unit.
Connection
Cellular or landline.
Battery Life
The rechargeable battery in the GoSafe2 pendant lasts 2 to 3 days.
Non-rechargeable batteries in pendant/wristband of HomeSafe devices. Philips Lifeline automatically checks battery status and sends a replacement device in case of need.
Over 48-hour battery back-up in the base unit.
Range (From in-home base unit to help button)
More than 800 feet.
Coverage Away From Home
Yes (GoSafe systems)
Fall Detection
It is included in the monthly fee of HomeSafe with GoSafe systems and Auto Alert.
GPS Locator
Yes (GoSafe systems)
24/7 USA Call Center
Yes
3

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Pros And Cons

Pros & Cons

Medical Guardian

Pro
  • No installation or activation fees.
  • A 14-day money-back period.
  • App-based location tracking.
  • Free spouse coverage.
  • TMA five diamond certified.
  • Standard and voice-activated wall buttons.
Cons
  • A lifetime guarantee costs extra.
  • No AARP member discounts.

Philips Lifeline

Pro
  • A 30-day free trial.
  • AARP member discounts.
  • Many fall detection sensors.
  • One-year guarantee.
  • Free with some Medicare Advantage plans.
  • Voice range extender.
Cons
  • No wall buttons.
  • No app-based location tracking.
  • No TMA five-diamond certification.
  • Installation and activation fees.
  • No free spouse coverage.
4

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Who Should Use?

Who Should Use?
  Medical Guardian Philips Lifeline
Target audiences
  • People have wiggle room in their budget.
  • Active seniors want the latest high-tech devices, such as a smartwatch system.
  • Older adults seek sleek equipment.
  • Families want a companion mobile app to track the users’ activity.
  • Users look for professional installation.
  • People want a simple system without whistles and bells.
  • Older people live in an area with reliable AT&T coverage.
  • Users want a provider with decades of industry experience.
5

Philips Lifeline And Medical Guardian: Contract

Contract
Medical GuardianPhilips Lifeline
Optional monthly add-on servicesFall detection (+$10 per month)
Lockbox
Not available
ContractNoNo
6

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: How Do They Cost?

How Much Do They Cost?
Starting Price
Activation Fee
Minimum Subscription
Lifetime Price Guarantee
Free Repairs & Replacements
Free Spouse Monitoring
Free Shipping
Medical Guardian
Medical Guardian
50% OFF
Check Prices
Starting Price
$29.95 per month
Activation Fee
No
Minimum Subscription
1 month
Lifetime Price Guarantee
Yes
Free Repairs & Replacements
Yes
Free Spouse Monitoring
No
Free Shipping
Yes (annual subscription)
Philips Lifeline
Philips Lifeline
No Current Deals
Check Prices
Starting Price
$29.95 per month
Activation Fee
$50
Minimum Subscription
1 month
Lifetime Price Guarantee
No
Free Repairs & Replacements
Not Available
Free Spouse Monitoring
No
Free Shipping
No

Now you know how much they cost, so where to buy them? Let’s click on the button below to own for yourself.

Medical Guardian and Philips Lifeline are two of the top medical alert providers. They built a competent and fast monitoring center, and their flexible cost is quite similar. Between Medical Guardian and Philips Lifeline, the former is the better medical alert device. Medical Guardian has more than 1400 feet of landline systems, free activation fees, replacements and repairs. Moreover, managing and ordering your subscription online with Medical Guardian is less hassle than with Philips Lifeline. WhichChoose hopes the Medical Guardian vs Philips Lifeline comparison provides the helpful information you are looking for.

Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Which Works Better?
Medical Guardian Vs Philips Lifeline: Which Works Better?
WhichChoose
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general